Hollywood has a long history of misrepresenting Mexico, portraying it as a lawless, corrupt, and violent land where crime and poverty reign. While some films attempt to address real social issues, many rely on exaggerated stereotypes that reduce the country to a bleak caricature.
The latest controversy surrounds “Emilia Pérez,” a French-Spanish musical about a Mexican drug lord who transitions into a woman. While praised internationally, the film has faced intense backlash in Mexico for its stereotypical depiction of the country. The criticism became so widespread that it even led to boycotts, government intervention, and backlash against Mexican filmmaker Guillermo del Toro for endorsing the film.
But «Emilia Pérez» is far from the first film to face criticism for its misguided portrayal of Mexico. Here are five other foreign-produced films that have left Mexico “badly represented” in the eyes of audiences.
1. Man on Fire (2004) – Kidnappings, Corruption, and a Grim Mexico City
The Problem:
- This action thriller, starring Denzel Washington, follows a retired police officer trying to rescue a kidnapped girl in Mexico City.
- The film depicts Mexico as a crime-ridden dystopia where kidnappings are routine, law enforcement is corrupt, and journalists trade sexual favors for information.
- Even Mexican actress Carmen Salinas is cast as a criminal, reinforcing the perception that Mexico is synonymous with organized crime.
Why It Matters:
While kidnapping is a real issue, Man on Fire presents an overly sensationalized version of Mexico, amplifying fear-mongering stereotypes about safety in the country.
2. Bordertown (2006) – The Feminicide Crisis Reduced to a Cliché
The Problem:
- Starring Jennifer Lopez, the film focuses on the unsolved murders of women in Ciudad Juárez.
- Rather than offering a nuanced examination of this issue, the movie paints Mexico as a desert wasteland with a permanently yellow filter, where even newsrooms lack computers.
Why It Matters:
The feminicide crisis in Mexico is a serious and ongoing human rights issue. However, Bordertown simplifies the problem into a cliched Hollywood narrative, failing to provide real insight into the systemic issues behind these crimes.
3. Get the Gringo (2012) – Mexican Prisons as Hell on Earth
The Problem:
- Starring Mel Gibson, the film follows a criminal sent to a Tijuana prison, which is portrayed as a chaotic, lawless nightmare where inmates rule over guards.
- The prison is a corrupt dystopia, where anything—including children carrying guns—is allowed.
Why It Matters:
While corruption in some Mexican prisons exists, Get the Gringo presents an extreme and unrealistic version of the penal system, reinforcing the narrative that Mexico operates outside the bounds of law and order.
4. Elysium (2013) – Mexico as Earth’s Dystopian Future
The Problem:
- In this sci-fi blockbuster, starring Matt Damon, Earth has become a polluted, overpopulated wasteland, while the wealthy live in a utopian space station called Elysium.
- The bleak, post-apocalyptic setting of Earth was filmed in actual impoverished neighborhoods in Mexico, reinforcing the stereotype that Mexico is synonymous with poverty and despair.
Why It Matters:
While wealth inequality is a global issue, Elysium erases Mexico’s rich culture, history, and progress, presenting it only as a place of suffering.
5. Sex and the City: The Movie (2008) – Mexico as a Backward, Dirty Country
The Problem:
- The film’s characters vacation in Los Cabos, Baja California, but refuse to eat Mexican food, fearing it will make them sick.
- One character suffers severe diarrhea after accidentally drinking shower water, reinforcing the idea that Mexico is unhygienic and unsafe for foreigners.
Why It Matters:
While water safety is a legitimate concern in some areas, Sex and the City perpetuates outdated and condescending stereotypes, suggesting that Mexico is inherently unsanitary.
Why These Stereotypes Matter
Films like these shape international perceptions of Mexico, reinforcing harmful biases that affect everything from tourism to diplomacy.
The Recurring Stereotypes
- Mexico as a crime-ridden wasteland (Man on Fire, Get the Gringo)
- Mexican women as perpetual victims (Bordertown)
- Mexico as a corrupt and lawless state (Get the Gringo)
- Mexico as a dystopian future (Elysium)
- Mexican food and water as dangerous (Sex and the City)
These portrayals oversimplify complex issues and ignore the diverse realities of Mexico—a country with thriving cities, cultural richness, and economic growth.
Moving Forward: Challenging Hollywood’s Narrative
While Hollywood has a long history of misrepresenting Mexico, recent films like Roma (2018) and Bardo (2022) showcase a more authentic perspective. However, for real change, the industry must:
- Hire Mexican filmmakers to tell their own stories.
- Move beyond stereotypes and explore Mexico’s diversity.
- Recognize Mexico’s contributions beyond crime and corruption.
Until then, audiences must remain critical of how Hollywood portrays Mexico, recognizing the difference between storytelling and perpetuating harmful myths.
Conclusion
From over-the-top crime stories to post-apocalyptic depictions, Hollywood has often reduced Mexico to a collection of stereotypes. Films like Man on Fire, Bordertown, and Elysium have shaped global perceptions of Mexico in ways that fail to reflect its true complexity.
While international audiences may not question these portrayals, Mexicans are increasingly pushing back against misrepresentation, demanding more accurate and respectful storytelling. Until Hollywood listens, these misleading narratives will continue to be challenged.
TE PODRÍA INTERESAR