Family of Valentina Gilabert Seeks to Reclassify Marianne ‘N’s Crime

The case of Valentina Gilabert, a 17-year-old allegedly stabbed more than 10 times by influencer Marianne ‘N’, has sparked intense legal and public debate. While Marianne ‘N’ was initially charged with aggravated assault, Valentina’s family is now pushing for a reclassification to attempted murder, arguing that the severity of the wounds and the attack’s nature indicate an intent to kill.

If the charge remains aggravated assault, Marianne ‘N’ could potentially post bail and walk free, a scenario the victim’s family is determined to prevent. They insist that this was a deliberate and violent act, not just a physical altercation.

The Case: What Happened to Valentina Gilabert?

According to reports, Marianne ‘N’ attacked Valentina Gilabert with a knife, causing severe injuries to her lungs, chest, and hand. The incident, described by the victim’s family as a brutal and premeditated attack, has led them to question the legal classification of the crime.

Key details of the case include:

• Multiple stab wounds, including injuries to vital organs.
• An escalation of violence, suggesting intent rather than a spontaneous act.
• The risk of Marianne ‘N’ being released on bail, which raises concerns for Valentina’s safety.

Why Valentina’s Family Insists It Was Attempted Murder

Valentina’s family argues that the crime should be reclassified as attempted murder based on:

1. The severity of the injuries
   • Stab wounds to vital areas like the lungs and chest suggest a life-threatening attack.
   • The sheer number of wounds indicates intent to kill, not just to injure.
2. The possibility of bail for Marianne ‘N’
   • Under the current aggravated assault charge, Marianne ‘N’ may avoid jail time if granted bail.
   • The family believes she poses a danger to society and should remain detained.
3. The argument that it was a premeditated attack
   • The level of violence and repetition of the stabbings supports the claim that Marianne ‘N’ intended to end Valentina’s life.

Legal Implications: Assault vs. Attempted Murder

Under Quintana Roo’s criminal code, the distinction between aggravated assault and attempted murder is crucial:

• Aggravated Assault: Involves causing serious injuries, especially with premeditation or the use of a weapon. Penalties vary based on the severity of injuries.
• Attempted Murder: Defined as an act intended to kill but failing to result in death. This charge carries a significantly harsher sentence.

The reclassification of the crime would mean a longer prison sentence for Marianne ‘N’, setting a legal precedent for similar cases.

What Could Be Marianne ‘N’s Defense Strategy?

While details on the defense’s approach remain unclear, legal experts speculate that her attorneys may argue:

• There was no intent to kill
  • They could claim the attack was an impulsive act rather than an attempt at murder.
• The wounds, although serious, were not fatal
  • They might argue that the injuries, while severe, did not directly threaten Valentina’s life, a key factor in attempted murder cases.

Expert Opinions on the Case’s Legal Complexity

Legal analysts have weighed in on whether the reclassification from aggravated assault to attempted murder is likely.

• Some experts believe the number of stab wounds strengthens the argument for attempted murder
• Others argue that without clear evidence of intent, the current charge may stand

This debate highlights the complexity of proving intent in violent crimes. The final ruling could impact how similar cases are prosecuted in the future.

Similar Cases: Could This Set a Legal Precedent?

In Mexico, there have been previous cases of violent attacks where families fought for reclassification. Some key trends include:

• Cases with multiple stab wounds have sometimes been upgraded to attempted murder
• Other cases remained classified as assault, particularly when intent was hard to prove

If Valentina’s case is reclassified, it could change the way violent knife attacks are prosecuted, potentially increasing penalties for perpetrators.

What’s Next for Valentina Gilabert and Her Family?

Valentina continues her recovery from life-threatening injuries, while her family fights for justice. Their goal is to ensure that Marianne ‘N’ faces the full weight of the law and does not evade accountability.Meanwhile, the legal battle intensifies, with public opinion strongly supporting the victim’s family. The outcome of this case could set a precedent for how violent crimes against young women are handled in Mexico.